A prostigious dinner Wednesday, Mar 22 2006
Tasting Notes and France and Bordeaux and Burgundy and Champagne and Variety and Red and White and Sparkling and chardonnay and cabernet et al and pinot noir
We had a very nice dinner last night at Tetsuyas. The picture on the right is of our wines enjoying the cool evening air before the dinner. I am doing the notes from memory so they will be vague and a bit shabby, but better than nothing I suppose.
Diebolt-Vallois Champagne 1999
This is a small maker champagne which the owner insisted was ‘much better than that coarse bubbled industrial swill’ Dom Perignon that is my preferred tipple. Anyway I am not much chop at writing notes on sparkling wine. This one was a creamy full bodied style with fine bubbles and excellent length. Liked it very much - not as much as Dom though. 93 points
Domaine J.N Gagnard Batard Montrachet 2001 - Grand Cru
Nice and open. Citrus, stonefruit, struck match and plenty of lovely spicy oak. Intense rich weighty palate with citrus, apricot and oak flavours. Creamy but with penetrating acidity. Very very long. Really needs time. Drink 2009-2017. 95+ points
Domaine Rousseau Le Chambertin 2000 - Grand Cru
Such a pretty colour - shining limpid ruby. Fragrant with raspberry liqueur and fresh raspberry, spice, roses, some sappy overtones. Smell constantly changing - some licorice later on. Fine raspberry/red fruit palate. Quite crisp. Everthing in balance. Great purity. Long and expansive on the finish. A ballerina. 96+ Points
Chateau Pichon Baron 1995 - Pauillac - 2nd growth
Open. Blackcurrant/cherry, cedar, tobacco and a fairly stong but attractive smoky/horsey smell. Rich fat palate with firm tannins. Not sweet but ripe. Earthy blackcurrant/plum flavours. Good length. Looked a bit shabby after the next wine was opened but still a good performer and an excellent wine.94 points
Chateau Cheval Blanc 1990 - St Emillon - Grand Cru
Joy of joys yet another meeting with my favourite wine of all time. Good colour. Beautiful smelling wine - raspberry, licorice, sweet dried herbs, spice, chocolate, charcoal. Perfect balance on the palate. Smooth and ripe but so elegant. Ridiculously long. Maybe I should give it a 100 points - everyone else did. 99 points
Chateau De Fargues 2001 Sauterne
A single estate wine made owned by the famous Lur Saluces family..and from a great vintage. Sulphur, oak, rich cumquat/apricot fruit. This one is a bit one dimensional at this stage. Needs another 20 years. I am not rating it now. I was an idiot for bringing this.
..and because we were still thirsty we ordered from the winelist.
Domaine Bernard Dugat-Py “Coeur de Roy” Vielles Vignes 1997 - AC Gevrey Chambertin
Smells very stongly of fresh cow poo and then red fruit. Opened up after a while and the fruit came up. Fine minerally slatey palate. Good finish. Hmmmm. I’ll make up a score. 91 points
Print this article
eMail this article
March 22nd, 2006 at 6:34 pm| Quote |
Lovely- How many for dinner, and was the food everything that it was supposed to be?
GD
March 22nd, 2006 at 6:36 pm| Quote |
Four for dinner.
Food very good - perhaps not quite as good as last time though - about a year ago.
GW
March 22nd, 2006 at 7:13 pm| Quote |
Walsh - you are a heathen.
Grant - The food was magnificent - probably even better than our previous visit. Remember - Gary has no palate (although he made the odd good call last night which suggests he is not a totally lost cause). The service was perfect, and the wines magically matched the content and pace of the 11 courses.
Diebolt-Vallois was sensational. Small growers rule. Gagnard Batard Montrachet will be an absolute ripper over time, as will the Rousseau Chambertin. Both stunning now though.
The poor old Pichon was quite excellent - until the majestic ‘90 Cheval was sat next to it. Walsh is kidding himself. 100 points. Not really a matter for discussion - as I said to Gary “What else could you possibly want from it?”.
Cheers
David
PS - I need to post quickly. I am sure Walsh will purge me once he realises I’m here!!
March 22nd, 2006 at 7:14 pm| Quote |
What the hell is this “moderation” thing?
March 22nd, 2006 at 7:20 pm| Quote |
The service was brilliant. They are magnificent at pacing the evening.
What else could I want from the 90 Cheval? I want it to be about $850 cheaper and available in 4 litre casks of course…failing that I am happy to drink your stash.
Yes. Quite appropriate for you to ask the meaning of the word “moderation”.
GW
March 22nd, 2006 at 7:27 pm| Quote |
Yes - felt a touch foggy today.
SAK was invented for wines like ‘90 Cheval.
PS - It’s easy to use and reply on this web-site. Like it Centurion, like it.
March 22nd, 2006 at 8:00 pm| Quote |
Dare I ask - how much is 90 Cheval?
March 22nd, 2006 at 8:11 pm| Quote |
“Diebolt-Vallois was sensational. Gagnard Batard Montrachet will be an absolute ripper over time”
I must stop agreeing with you DCB.. but it’s hard not to.
The 90 Cheval was perfection.
March 22nd, 2006 at 8:16 pm| Quote |
Lincoln - I think it was about $900 plus commission at Langton’s. Bliss doesn’t come cheap.
Jo - It’s amazing what renowned palates can taste. Although Grasshopper fared reasonably well …….. considering.
March 22nd, 2006 at 8:27 pm| Quote |
I must try the 90 Cheval. I must. The problem is that I am not over Burgundy yet. Can one have two mistresses at the same time?
March 22nd, 2006 at 8:29 pm| Quote |
The 90 Cheval was $918 including commission.
GW
March 23rd, 2006 at 8:44 am| Quote |
Lincoln - Yes.
Gary - Are you an accountant or something?
March 23rd, 2006 at 9:24 am| Quote |
Never had a Cheval Blanc, much to my dismay. I am quite ashamed.
A friend in Europe told me last week that he went to a private dinner where they opened 9 bottles of 1990 Cheval Blanc, amongst others. That sounds very renowned.
GD
March 23rd, 2006 at 9:34 am| Quote |
That would be exactly the right amount amongst 4 people…and reasonable host would do the same.
GW
March 23rd, 2006 at 3:37 pm| Quote |
Yes, quite…I guess what i’m saying is that i’m insanely jealous of everyone who is gorging themselves on this sort of booze. Stop it or you’ll go blind.
March 24th, 2006 at 3:08 pm| Quote |
Gary,
Very nice dinner. Pleased to hear about the 90 Cheval - i last tried it 5 yrs ago and it was very promising then. Diebolt sounds good too - I have a little stash due tomorrow.
Rousseau Chambertin - yum! teh 01 is just about my wine of the year thus far.
Cheers,
Kent
March 28th, 2006 at 1:16 pm| Quote |
I have been moving a bottle of 90 Cheval in DCB’s cellar.
I haven’t actually stolen it yet, but I move it 7cm towards the door each time I am there.
I’ll drink it in an ISO with fish and chips.